Monday, January 14, 2013

Reviews: The Great Divorce C.S. Lewis By Heidi Moyer


          C. S. Lewis wrote The Great Divorce with the intent of portraying the inevitable consequences of day-to-day behaviors. A constant theme flowing through the pages of this book was, “Evil can be undone, but it cannot ‘develop’ into good.” (TGD pg. VIII) No length of time will make it go away, however if evil is unwound like a ball of yarn, piece by piece it can be undone and turned to good. Lewis expressed his feelings concerning false faith and things of that sort. He also critiqued the culture and art of that time. There were also individuals and people criticized. He included all this in his engaging fantasy about one man’s trip through Heaven and Hell.
            The protagonist was first met on a rainy afternoon at a bus stop. There was a vast variety of people present. Some seemed to be irritable while some seem eager to please others. A few appeared to be restless and ready to pick a fight. Then the bus pulled up, it shone with a blazing golden glow that was unimaginable. The driver himself had an air of authority and light shining through him. Once in the bus they flew off and soon came to the grey town otherwise known as the valley of the shadow of death. There was something peculiar about the town, it was covered with houses as far as the eye can see, but it was sparsely populated. The people of this town were incredibly quarrelsome. Within twenty-four hours neighbors would move away from each other, and the cycle continues forever. In this town the people do not have any needs because one only has to think of something and it is there. However, nothing is real. A house could be there but it could not keep out rain. It is a spiritual city. “When the daylight comes, comes in the light.’ And that passion for ‘real’ commodities which our friends speak of is only materialism, you know. It’s retrogressive. Earth-bound! A hankering for matter.” (TGD pg. 16) This quote reveals how one got a taste of something real such as light; it puts a desirous feeling in a person to crave material positions.  
            After the bus riders left the city they came to beautifully indescribable and large expanse, this country was known as the valley of the shadow of life. “It made solar system seem indoor”. (TGD pg. 20) Also everything there brought the word solid to a new level because everything they had previously known to be solid now seemed a poor substitute for the solid of this land. Once the people on the bus got off they all seemed like phantoms or smudges on a painting. They were like “man shaped stains on the brightness of the air”. (TGD pg. 20) The flowers seemed to have the strength or hardness as diamonds. Even the leaves were unable to be picked up. Then the bright beings that were strong, solid, and smooth skinned came up to meet the ghost like people who shook in terror. A being went up to each person it was someone which they had known that had past on. They talked to the ghosts about their lives and things they needed to adjust. Some listened and followed the beings while others went back to the grey town. The ones who went into the mountains became solid over time. Once they became solid they could travel throughout the country and up into the deep Heaven or mountains with ease.
            The man’s teacher, George McDonald said, “Ye cannot know eternal reality by a definition. Time itself, and all acts and events that fill Time, are the definition, and it must be lived.” (TGD pg. 141) This quote expresses that one cannot explain or interpret eternal reality with words; instead they have to live it out. His teacher then told him that he had yet to make those decisions and that he was in a dream. After that he woke up in a cold room with the clock striking three o’clock.
            In this engaging fable, Lewis incorporated his feelings concerning false faith. “One will say he has always served his country right or wrong; and another that he has sacrificed everything to his art.” (TGD pg. 70) This example of a false faith was extreme patriotism. This can be a false faith because if someone feels very strongly about their country and will do anything for it, it can become an obsession. One could even go to the extent of worshiping their nation’s leader. Also, some people serve their country whether or not it was morally right or not. Another form of false faith acknowledged in this book is self-love. The main fault of this choice of religion or belief was that it was usually to the disadvantage of others. Another false religion was art. Art can become an idol or an object of worship when one puts all of their time, energy, and money into it. Lust cannot as easily become a religion because, “Lust is a poor, weak, whimpering, whispering thing compared with that richness and energy of desire which will arise when lust has been killed.” (TGD pg. 114) It just sneaks its way into people’s lives.
            Lewis critiqued the culture of his time. He talked about communism and capitalism, stating that, “Capitalism did not merely enslave the workers, it also vitiated taste and vulgarized intellect: hence our educational system and hence the lack of ‘Recognition’ for new genius.” (TGD pg. 7) This quote was packed with Lewis’ feelings about government criticism and criticism of the educational system. He suggests that capitalism has ruined intellectual opportunities thus the condition of the deteriorating public school system. Because our school system was so poor, true genius was not being recognized.   
            Lewis criticized different people and groups of people in this book. In the beginning of the book Lewis described some of the characters, comparing their different personalities. The first group he criticized was people who were intellectually minded that believed to have no sin. However this is what Lewis said to them, “Do you really think there are no sins of intellect? There is indeed, Dick. There is hide-bound prejudice, and intellectual dishonesty, and timidity, and stagnation. But honest opinions fearlessly followed--they are not sins.” (TGD pg. 36). Another group he criticized was people who believe they did not need God. In one interview a Ghost said, “I gone straight all my life. I don’t say I was a religious man and I don’t say I had no faults, far from it. But I done my best all my life, see? I done my best by everyone, that’s the sort of chap I was.” (TGD pg. 27) This quote shows the attitude of one of the ghosts, he felt like he was just as good as the next guy or better. “I forgave him as a Christian, said the Ghost. But there are some things one can never forget.” (TGD pg. 89) In other interviews such as this one individuals struggled with forgiveness. The last group he criticized was people who were unforgiving to themselves and others. Christ forgave the worlds inhabitants even before they were born if they would accept His gift, so people need to be willing to forgive themselves as well as others. Lewis specifically criticized George McDonald, whose works and ways of thinking had a profound influence on him. In the book, Lewis states that Holiness is a quality evident in McDonald’s books.
            The Great Divorce shows traces of being influenced by post-modernism. “We simply found ourselves in contact with a certain current of ideas and plunged in to it because it seemed modern and successful.” (TGD pg. 36-37) This quote discussed ignoring the old ideas and jumping in to new ideas because they are new. “… and all the time it was apparently haunted by the terror of discovery” (TGD pg. 47-48) This quote states that sometimes it is hard to discover new things because it might prove the old things wrong.            
            Brilliantly, Lewis produced The Great Divorce. It is a tale that has turned the hearts of many to the Lord. He blended his critiques, compliments, and ideas perfectly. Lewis used his intelligence and writing techniques to explain his views of the after life.


Bibliography :
Lewis, C. S.Great divorce a dream. [San Fracisco]: HarperSanFrancisco, 2001.                                                                                                           
            

No comments:

Post a Comment